seccción book vs. film, I will compare a book with one or several adaptations peliculeras, I hope you enjoy.
El_desertor presents the first game of the season:
The Incredible Walk
vs road to freedom
The road is clear
El_desertor presents the first game of the season:
The Incredible Walk
vs road to freedom
The road is clear
| adaptation | Quality:3-It is different but not bad | Score bookLLLLL " But as far I could live without reading it? | movie rating: ** / | ***best: | some scenes in the desso this criticism, in the background is the contrast between an ideal and a memory hazy current and fresh.The main problem of adaptation, I think it is a fundamental part in the novel, it does highlight the fact is the time, the novel really perceive the brutality, the magnitude of the event, and perceive the fragility of man versus nature. | Although there is an origin "policy" of the plot in the novel, at bottom, is a part of the long walk, which starts after the interrogation, conviction and the inhumane train ride to Siberia, elements that are almost comparable to the Gobi desert heat or the cold wind of the tundra. Is shown as a ruthless realitiesand feeling that "long walk."|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SMALL SPOILER: One fact that struck me and does not appear in the movie-eventually cut their losses and "saves" by taking away the Himalayas reaching importance, is the fact the natural and emphasis of the facts. Death certainly does not appear on purpose, it is sudden, brutal. One of the companions are exploring the mountain pass as a way of India and freedom, and disappears, just walking through a snowy field, covering a crack and plunges. Occurs in half a page, sudden, silent, no one can find his body, no one can o & iacute; r their last request. Is authentic, impressive, dramatic. You've been walking with him one year, through the taiga, desert, forest, and suddenly, when you're coming with him at journey's end, after many challenges ; you overcome, a minor error it disappear for ever before your eyes. That moment left me in shock. | COMBAT VERDICT: Definitely the movie is dull, has some interesting moments, but does not compare to the intensity and excitement of the book, would not this script in the hands of another, Weird is pe
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
|
0 comments:
Post a Comment